It’s so easy, maybe even too easy to point the finger of blame for today’s financial crisis at former Federal Reserve Chairman, Alan Greenspan.
There, I said it! And coming to the defense of Alan Greenspan on Wall Street these days might even brand me a fiscal heretic. On the “Street”, where I’ve had the comically questionable fortune to know many would-be economic aficionados with cloudy green eye shades, just the mere mention of Greenspan sends people into imitations of Linda Blair’s head spin in the Exorcist. But pea soup and doll swirls aside; In my humble opinion, Chairman Greenspan is not the demon responsible for the current financial systemic malaise. But, before I reveal the devil himself to you my avid reader, let me offer a little defense for Dr. Greenback.
In today’s Wall Street Journal there’s an article by David Wessel which notes that as early as 2002, according to minutes from Fed meetings, Chairman Greenspan was quoted as saying, “It’s hard to escape the conclusion that at some point our extraordinary housing boom….cannot continue indefinitely into the future.” So this tells me that Chairman Greenspan was not asleep at the switch, but cognizant of the potential dangers and inevitable decline. The article goes on the note that Greenspan believed that if there was a decline, it would not pose a significant threat too the entire financial system. This was not an irrationally exuberant or wishful thought at the time. No one would have believed at the time that the housing market would experience a severe and precipitous decline.
So Alan Greenspan’s position both privately and publicly was that if there was going to be a decline, it would not be severe. Thus all of you with pointing fingers and loaded guns aimed at Alan Greenspan, who want to fault Chairman Greenspan for leaving the punch bowl out at the party for too long, please settle down. Get a hold of yourself and put that six shooter back in the holster. Chairman Greenspan was, as Thomas Friedman would say, dealing with an entirely new paradigm called a global economy, and can not be singularly blamed for today’s financial catastrophe.
Ok…now to the real demon behind today’s systemic problem and fiscal crisis.
Simply put, (yes simply put as from a 30,000 foot view), it is and has been the worldwide perception that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac - the holders of over $5 trillion of real estate debt, are government insured entities backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. taxpayer (notice I did not say government). This was the perception… meaning that even though it wasn’t the reality, investors world wide always believed (or better yet, ‘wanted to believe’) that should there be a housing market collapse – because these entities were ‘government sponsored,” the government would simply change the word sponsored to insured. Heck…its just a little 7 letter word right?
So the
So the devil is alive and well, and the flames of future failure on a scale even larger than what we have already seen remains a very real possibility. One has to wonder if we’ll ever learn the lesson from the Japanese real estate bust, and the debilitating period of deflation, the embers of which are still glowing in that economy. One has got to wonder how long the Chinese, Japanese and the British will be willing to support the irresponsible policies of the
Posted in Commentary | 3 Comments »

